| growth | epistemic status |
|---|---|
| 🫘 seed | 👣 exploratory |
| Dignity strikes me as being about rights, for some reason: it is undignified to be deprived of one’s rights. Sure enough, the SEP entry has a lot on that note. So there is dignity related to external forces - the way we are treated - but also dignity related to internal forces - a feeling about the way we have conducted ourselves. As such, dignity is necessarily dependent on ethics, and values. If I have not harmed anyone, and my activities were felt to be worthwhile, I can feel dignity. |
Wordnik has ‘the quality/state of being worthy of esteem or respect’; and ‘inherent nobility’, which is where dignity overlaps with certain qualities cultivated by any Buddhist practitioner but especially the sangha of ‘noble disciples’, who are deemed worthy of such esteem and nobility on the grounds of those qualities. Considering these qualities give us a place to start considering what we can do to start cultivating dignity if we feel it is lacking.
The association with nobility even in non-Buddhist contexts is telling about how powerful and important dignity is: one of dignity has agency and sovereignty, autonomy, in their fate or future; when they lose that autonomy, they fall to the state of a serf in the kingdom of their own life. However we might feel about actual free will, having the autonomy to make our own choices is valued by most people, at least.
It is undignified to feel one is trading their time to do work they find meaningless or worse, for the profit of someone else, who one usually doesn’t know - an anonymous capitalist employer or state service.
From the prominence of funeral homes and obituary services in the search results, it seems dignity has much to do with how we have spent our lives. Interesting to note that aging and dying with dignity are more important than dignity in early life, where maturity is valued but there is more room, ideally, around learning how to become dignified - more margin for error perhaps. And it seems tied with something like self-consciousness/awareness. Being reduced to nappies in late life might feel undignified, but a baby is not concerned.
There is a social aspect of dignity as well, with some saying that individual dignity is dependent upon the dignity of the species, in the same sense others say individual freedom is dependent upon the freedom of all other individuals.