👈🏼 from Seeking an Alternative

The more I learn about and experience bhāvanā, psychological cultivation, the more I realise this needs to be my priority. I agree we need to co-create an alternative to the direction society is headed, but the priority of my means for contributing have changed, partly because I seem to have assimilated the cyclical cosmology of Buddhism - or if not assimilated, then I simply recognised in Buddhism a cosmology that made more sense to me in the first place.

Literary activism lost its appeal, for probably two major reasons: it feels borderline hubristic to think I have anything to say about reality that will improve things in a meaningful way; and prioritising cultivation is the minimal foundation upon which any helping is going to be actually helpful. Writing becomes a practice that supports cultivation, and as such this site is at least a playground where I can explore ideas for that purpose.

Previously it was blogs and the occasional essay but the digital garden provides a format and a CMS that supports a more explorative and meandering way of thinking. A thought can peter out without concluding here, like an unwalked trail out of the garden into the woods, and this helps me move away from attachment to linear progress by increasing uncertainty and ambiguity tolerance, because contradicting ideas can co-exist here in a way that may be more supported by non-linear writing.

But as a means of helping, yeah, it seems increasingly conceited that any ideas I have might improve upon reality - my task is to improve my relationship with reality, not to improve reality. I need to correct my relationship with reality - align my perception with truth - and in doing so I become an agent for social change without necessarily advocating for any change. I become the change, which is a cliche for a reason.

I guess the motive to change the world comes from the missionary impulse encouraged in Christianity, and I think in Islam. Or the motive for the missionary comes from the impulse to change the world, to institute a preferred order of reality. It’s a chicken-egg thing I suppose, and related to the experience of many Westerners interpreting Buddhism through a soteriological lens borrowed from Christianity.

We fell from grace, and need absolution from an external God before we can be eternally happy somewhere else - in a realm that is fundamentally different from our earthly domain. When we find an representative of such an external force, a saviour, of course we want to share that with others, and any avid dhamma practitioner is quick to share what they know about Buddhism. But there is not the same missionary impulse, not the same compulsion to convince others, and in traditional Buddhist countries there is no question about whether ordaining for life, dedicating oneself to the training of their own heart and mind, is a worthwhile thing to do. It is just the trappings of my inherited worldview that sometimes weigh me down with doubts draped over an otherwise healthy confidence that making such a commitment is the only real way to help.

And it seems easier to change the world, because it has tangible touch points, whereas changing oneself is an amorphous, nebulous endeavour, and scary. But we don’t need soteriology when the world is not the problem, when reality is not the problem, but our misperception of reality. And what if the world is perfect as it is, replete with all its imperfection? The problem is we misperceive reality, and therefore suffer unnecessarily.

To resolve the problem of our misperception, we need to start with cultivation of external and psychological conditions that support concentration and insight. This is how I change the world - in this fathom-long body, by prioritising cultivation. Any helping that is conducted without such cultivation as the foundation is liable to slide into codependency and spiritual bypassing.